top of page
3 hours ago
8 min read


TECHTONICS


THE INVENTION OF THE ACCIDENT: A TESLA IN TORONTO

MAGGIE VEEN

November 19, 2026



Every invention comes with a promise. It also brings into the world a particular kind of trouble that did not exist before. We discover the trouble later, sometimes in the most ridiculous circumstances. This is a story about an electric automobile, a parking attendant, and a door that would not open.

The only time I rented a fully electric car, it ran out of electricity. I did not repeat the experiment.

 

I got my driver’s license the day I turned eighteen, in the late 1980s, when cars made noise, needed oil changes, occasionally refused to start, and could usually be fixed by someone who knew what to do with a wrench. I still like that kind of car: the sound of an engine accelerating, the small physical negotiations between driver, road, and machine. Perhaps I am old-fashioned, or a traditionalist. I am not sure there is a difference. I know the arguments for electric vehicles and the arguments against them, and I am not qualified to settle them. My resistance is less rational than that. I like the automobile as I have known it.

 

A few weeks ago, I saw something that made my own dead battery seem minor.

 

There is an underground garage in Yorkville, a well-to-do Toronto neighborhood. Attendants take your vehicle, hand you a ticket, and drive it somewhere into the depths of the building. A car rental counter shares the space.

 

Ontario’s plates say, “Yours to Discover.” On level P2, this included the door handle.

 

One afternoon, after returning a rental car, I was walking toward the exit when I noticed a man standing beside a Tesla, talking to one of the attendants. The car would not start. The attendant said he had seen this before and offered to take a look. I slowed down. I was curious whether this was another car that had simply run out of energy.

 

The attendant got into the driver’s seat and closed the door. He touched the screen, waited, and tried again. Nothing happened.

 

Parking is ordinarily a two-part job. You get in, you park, and getting out hardly counts as a separate operation.

 

Then he tried to get out. The door would not open. He tried again. Still nothing. The owner, outside, seemed unconcerned. “Just wait a moment. It’ll unlock.” It did not. A bystander suggested that the owner unlock the car with the Tesla app on his phone. “Yes, yes, I know,” the owner said. “That’s what I’m trying to do.” The man offered to help. The owner said he knew what he was doing, and the man left. I stayed.

 

The attendant pressed every control he could find, with no effect. He and the owner were shouting to each other through the closed window. The owner explained that Tesla could unlock the car remotely. He would call an emergency number, prove who he was, and someone at a computer, perhaps a thousand miles away, would release the doors of a car parked two floors under Toronto.

 

He called. To my surprise, a human being answered almost at once: no recording about high call volumes, no music. He put the call on speaker. He explained that his car would not start and that a parking attendant was locked inside, then gave his name, the vehicle identification number, and whatever else was needed. The representative said they would try to connect to the car.

 

In 1910, The Detroit Electric advertised a “centralization of responsibility.” If anything went wrong, at least you knew whom to write to.

 

We waited. Nothing happened. The car had no signal. We were two floors underground, surrounded by concrete. The owner’s phone worked fine, but the Tesla could not reach anyone. “I can’t locate your vehicle,” the representative said.

 

“So what am I supposed to do?”

 

The representative described a procedure in which the owner and I should pull on different doors at particular intervals. This might reset something or let the connection through. I did not understand the explanation, and I am not sure the owner did, either. But we tried. Nothing.

 

The attendant was losing patience. He had cars to park and tickets to issue, and his colleagues were facing a growing line. “There must be a manual release somewhere,” someone said. But nobody knew where. The attendant felt under the dashboard, around the door, behind the screen. From outside, I watched him disappear below the steering wheel, come back up, and descend again, like a man looking for a lost coin in a very expensive sofa.

 

More people arrived, each with a theory. Disconnect the battery. Restart it from the screen. Call a mechanic. Press several things at once. The owner listened to none of it. He stayed on the phone, sure that Tesla would fix it.

 

I had been there twenty minutes by then. I could have left, but I stayed because this had become interesting, which is not an admirable reason to watch a trapped man. I had no theory and no tools. I also did not say what I was thinking, which was: Break the window. Inside the car, the attendant gave up on hidden buttons and started pulling and pushing on the door.

 

“Stop that!” the owner shouted. “You’ll damage my car!” The attendant shouted something back that I could not make out through the glass. The owner turned back to his phone. “Yes, I’m still here. No, nothing has happened.” Another five minutes passed. The attendant began kicking the door from inside. “Stop kicking my car!” The owner seemed to treat the attendant’s predicament as a problem for the car, not for the man inside it. After nearly forty minutes, the attendant kicked through a window. Glass scattered across the concrete. He climbed out, brushed himself off, and went straight for the owner.

 

“Why did you destroy my car?”

 

“What was I supposed to do? Stay in there forever?”

 

The owner and the attendant could now hear each other perfectly.

 

The attendant explained, in less than polite language, that he had a job to do, that people were waiting, and that he could not spend his afternoon imprisoned in somebody’s automobile. He had some angry words about expensive gadgets and the people who could afford them while others worked for a living. The owner said the attendant had caused unnecessary damage.

 

One man had wanted to protect his car. The other had wanted to get out of it. The owner could not see why the attendant had not simply waited; the attendant could not see why anyone would build a car a person could not escape. I was on the side of the latter.

 

The Tesla, I should add, was no gleaming luxury object. It was an older model, a bit dirty, with a tired interior. The owner defended it as if it were priceless. Eventually the argument ran out. The attendant went back to work, the crowd drifted off, and the owner stood beside his car, still holding his phone.

 

The representative was still on the line. “Hello? Hello? What happened? Can you give me an update?” The owner did not answer but rather assessed the damage. The problem had been solved, though not by technology.

 

The blue arrow would have been a welcome addition to the actual car.

 

There was still the matter of getting the car out. It could not be driven, and a tow truck could not fit into the garage, so a smaller vehicle would have to pull it up to the street. Then the brakes would not release. The car had refused to start, refused to unlock, and refused to talk to its manufacturer. Now it refused to move. I had been in the garage for almost an hour. I left, and I never found out how they got the Tesla out. I figured the best part of this story was behind us.

 

Later I looked up the manual release. Most Teslas have a mechanical release for the front doors within reach of the driver. On the Model 3 and Model Y, it is a small lever just in front of the window switches. The way out had been right at the attendant’s hand the entire time, and nobody in the garage, including the owner, knew it was there.

 

An electric car going somewhere on somebody else’s wheels.

 

What I saw was not a freak event, either. A car that won’t start, won’t unlock and won’t release its brakes sounds a lot like a Tesla whose small 12-volt battery, the one that runs its electronics, has died. In September 2025, US regulators opened an investigation into 2021 Model Ys after parents reported that the electronic door handles had stopped working, apparently from low battery voltage, with children locked in the back seat. In four cases, the parents broke a window to get in. In February 2026, responding to fatal crashes in which electronic doors failed, China announced that starting in 2027, every car sold there must have mechanical door releases inside and out.

 

None of this is a case against electric propulsion. A gasoline car can have electrical failures and jammed locks, too. What bothered and amused me in equal measure was that the car had become a system nobody present could operate. The owner could not run it. The attendant could not leave it. The manufacturer could not reach it. No one in the crowd could help. The car had stopped being a machine and become a sealed box.

 

The French theorist Paul Virilio argued that every invention also invents its own accident: “When you invent the ship, you also invent the shipwreck.” The railway made derailment possible, and the airplane, the plane crash. The automobile was invented to give people freedom of movement. This one had taken away a man’s freedom to move at all.

 

Paul Virilio, who saw the shipwreck in the invention of the ship. The parking garage was Maggie’s contribution.

 

The owner had bought a sophisticated machine and did not know how to reactivate it when it failed. The manufacturer could supposedly reach in from a distance, but could not. The attendant had neither designed nor bought the car, and he was the one locked inside. When he got out by the most basic means available, he was accused of destroying property. The benefits belong to the person who owns the machine. The accident may belong to someone else; Virilio does not address this.

 

My attachment to the combustion engine is hard to defend, on environmental grounds among others, and nothing that happened in that garage made it more or less defensible. What has changed is that I no longer assume a more sophisticated machine necessarily makes life easier or safer. Sometimes it takes a problem once solved by turning a handle and makes it depend on specialized knowledge, a remote operator, and a phone signal.

 

In the garage, a man spent forty minutes trying to open a door. In the end, he used his foot.

 


Margaret (Maggie) Venn was born in Thunder Bay, Ontario, in 1968. She worked as a flight attendant for Air Canada for nearly twenty-five years before moving into airport operations, where she now coordinates passenger services and ground staff. She lives in Toronto, enjoys driving, and has a long-standing interest in the ways modern conveniences complicate everyday life. She has considerable experience with things that are supposed to move but do not.


Cover image: The garage, to its credit, has clearly marked the exit.

 
 
 

Comments


selavy-logo.png

A CABINET OF CURIOSITIES ASSEMBLED IN PROSE

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE UPDATES ON NEW POSTINGS FROM SÉLAVY

EMAIL ADDRESS:

THANKS FOR SIGNING UP!

bottom of page