top of page
21 minutes ago
12 min read

SONGS AND SOUNDS


WHEN DIKA NEWLIN MET ARNOLD SCHOENBERG

ELISE MARET

November 17, 2026



Dika Newlin was still a teenager when she left East Lansing for Los Angeles to study composition with Arnold Schoenberg. Her diary of those lessons would become a book. Her own compositions included a piano trio and, some years later, a piece that required her to eat Rice Krispies into a microphone in a Texas concert hall. She called it “Serial Music.” Twenty years after her death, both are worth hearing.

“He thinks Verdi is a great composer. I do not concur.” The critic was Dika Newlin, an American teenager taking composition lessons in Los Angeles. The gentleman whose judgment on Verdi she found wanting was Arnold Schoenberg. She recorded their difference of opinion in her diary, where, secure in the knowledge that only one of them had access to the proceedings, she generally allowed him a fair hearing. We have no account of what Schoenberg said on Verdi’s behalf. A pity. One would gladly give up several of the surviving explanations of twelve-tone composition to hear Arnold Schoenberg make the case for Rigoletto to a girl from East Lansing.

 

Dika Newlin with her first book. Three composers made the title. The fourth wrote it.

 

Newlin died in Richmond, Virginia, on July 22, 2006—twenty years ago. Readers encountering her then might have gathered from the obituaries that a onetime pupil of Schoenberg’s had lived long enough to dye her hair and sing in a punk band. Both ends of the story were true, and the distance between them offered an obituary writer certain inducements. The middle is harder to come by. There is a piano trio, for instance, whose opening notes she laid out with care, and whose last chord contains every one of them. There is an article in which she undertook to explain something about Schoenberg’s piano concerto that appears to have escaped a good many pianists. There is also the matter of how the two of them came to be discussing Italian opera in California in the first place.

 

In September 1938, Newlin, aged fourteen, left East Lansing by train with her mother. Her father stayed in Michigan. A conductor named Vladimir Bakaleinikoff had taken an interest in her compositions and urged the family to send her to Schoenberg. Bakaleinikoff had worked in Hollywood and knew enough about the musical life of Southern California to make a recommendation that would scarcely have occurred to a guidance counselor. It required an adjustment in the domestic arrangements. An adult who wanted instruction could correspond with a prospective teacher and buy their own ticket. A fourteen-year-old needed someone else to buy a second ticket, pack up her own life, and go too. Mrs. Newlin’s part in the history of American composition deserves those few lines in the family history, even if the rest of the story is usually told from the daughter’s perspective.

 

In September 1938, Dika Newlin and her mother took the train to Los Angeles. A composition lesson for one required two tickets.

 

Five years earlier, the same advice would have sent the family in the opposite direction. Schoenberg, born in Vienna in 1874, had a master class at the Prussian Academy of Arts in Berlin. But in 1933 the Nazis took power, and a Jewish composer, however eminent, had no future teaching at a German state institution. He left Germany, formally rejoined the Jewish faith in Paris, and crossed the Atlantic that autumn. After a winter teaching in the US Northeast, where the weather did his health little good, he moved to Los Angeles. There he taught privately, lectured at the University of Southern California, and eventually joined the faculty at UCLA. By the time the train came in from Michigan, one could obtain an education in Viennese composition at a public university within easy reach of the Pacific Ocean.

 

California has done very well thanks to the retrospective glamour of certain European émigrés. Thomas Mann, Billy Wilder, Schoenberg, the houses, the addresses, the proximity of the studios. One particularly satisfactory piece of casting placed Shirley Temple across the street from the Schoenbergs in Brentwood. There was another Los Angeles, however, visible in a newspaper advertisement announcing that the composer had moved to Hollywood with his family and was accepting students. Pauline Alderman, who taught music herself, saw it and signed up. Here was a man who until recently had occupied one of the leading composition posts in Europe, now advertising for pupils in the local paper. She was a woman already professionally employed who realized she could now take lessons from him.

 

Dika Newlin had an advantage over most historians in that she was principally interested in what was going to happen to Dika Newlin. Her diary consequently preserves a Los Angeles in which Schoenberg had papers to mark, students with exasperating handwriting, and afternoons that could disappear into the correction of a single measure. When the class was assigned variations, she brought in seven. Nobody else, she observed, managed more than three. She was willing to record criticism of herself, particularly if the diary entry allowed room for an independent assessment of the pupil whose superior penmanship the teacher had just held up as an example. Those of us who have taught might spare a thought for the others in the room. One of the less obvious risks of taking a university course is that the most gifted and least charitable member of the class will someday publish her notes.

 

What exactly had she crossed the country to learn? Schoenberg had developed a way of composing with all twelve notes of the chromatic scale, arranging them in an order that could furnish material for a whole piece. The order could be reversed, its intervals turned upside down, or the whole sequence begun on another pitch. What it could scarcely tell a composer was whether the next passage ought to move quickly, whether the cello should come in now or four measures later, or whether, having got the cello in, there was anything worth giving it to play. In December 1940, Newlin recorded an extraordinary admission. Schoenberg doubted his ability to teach anyone to write twelve-tone music. He worked so much by instinct that, should something go wrong, he could hardly explain how to put it right himself. It is an odd predicament for the inventor of a method, particularly one whose name would become practically interchangeable with the method in American music departments.

 

He could, on the other hand, teach someone to write a set of variations, carry an independent line against another, or recognize the moment at which an idea has given as much as it can give. For a pupil already conscious of her originality, it was a rigorous introduction to the quantity of ordinary work that originality entails. By June 1941 Newlin had a string quartet being performed and a sufficiently complicated relationship with her teacher to consider boycotting her own concert. In the end she went, installed herself at the back of the auditorium, and wore a hat with a veil. In her account, this gave Schoenberg some anxious moments over the possibility that she had left town without saying goodbye. Whether it actually did is unknowable. The hat is a fact of the first order. Thirty years before her career in performance art, Newlin had already grasped that one could attend a concert as a member of the audience by making effective use of a costume.

 

In 1942, Schoenberg received a request from Oscar Levant, the American pianist, for a modest piano piece. The result was a concerto for piano and orchestra, a drastic revision of the original brief. At the opening, the piano has a tune with time to unfold and the swaying measure of a waltz. In the sketches, Schoenberg attached a few sentences in English to the course the work would take. The first was “Life was so easy.” The next, “Suddenly hatred broke out.” They were working notes, and one ought to respect the difference between a few words a composer finds useful at his desk and a story his audience is expected to recognize from the stalls. Yet there is something affecting about the choice of language. The man who once taught in Berlin had written himself a reminder, in English, of the ease with which a life could once be lived. In the concerto, the waltz is already twelve-tone music.

 

Schoenberg’s sketch for the Piano Concerto, Op. 42. “Life was so easy,” he wrote at the top of the page. The pianist might like a word.


Newlin eventually published an essay on the concerto with the faintly conspiratorial title “Secret Tonality in Schoenberg’s Piano Concerto.” She took the opening melody apart and proposed that, beneath the twelve-tone writing, the ear could still find its bearings in relation to C. Under the notes of the piano’s right hand she set Roman numerals of the sort generations of students had used to identify harmonies in Beethoven. There are objections to her analysis, among them that the pianist also has a left hand. As Edward Pick later pointed out, adding the notes played by that hand can change the name one would give a chord in the other. Her argument is worth reading alongside the objections because she risked being specifically wrong. She identified the bars, named the harmonies, and left subsequent pianists free to take the matter up with ten fingers. One could scarcely ask for a more durable form of disagreement between a pupil and a teacher who had been dead for over twenty years.

 

Her own piano trio, written in 1948, gives some idea of what interested her in the concerto well before she sat down to analyze it in print. The piano begins by stating the twelve notes from which she will make the piece. First G, then F, then A. Nothing especially outlandish so far. By the time the sequence has run its course, each of the twelve pitch classes has appeared, though anyone hoping to reconstruct the remainder of the piece from this information alone has about as much to go on as a reader supplied with the alphabet in the order in which the letters first occur in a novel. What the ear has to work with is more particular. A waltz turns up here, too. A more expansive tune follows, then a march.

 

Newlin used the word “portmanteau” to describe the form. Several movements fit inside one, with the scherzo and the slow section occurring where a classical sonata would ordinarily go to work on its opening ideas. The arrangement has a consequence one can follow without a score. Late in the trio, the cello takes up the scherzo tune at a slower pace while the pianist plays material from the adagio. Two episodes that took place at different times can now occupy the same time. At the end, the notes the piano had been at pains to introduce individually arrive together in one enormous chord. A listener who has lost track of the original sequence, as most of us will have, can still appreciate the change in the terms of acquaintance.

 

In the summer of 1952, Newlin went to Salzburg to play the piano part herself. The International Society for Contemporary Music’s festival archive places the trio between two chamber concerts of the Third International Twelve-Tone Congress, in the Wiener Saal of the Mozarteum. Beside each composer, the archive gives a country. Mátyás Seiber, born in Hungary, appears under the United Kingdom. Ernst Krenek, born in Austria, appears under the United States. Beside Newlin’s name, the entry is refreshingly straightforward. An American born in Oregon was performing a piece she had written in the Viennese tradition after studying it in California. Schoenberg had died in Los Angeles the previous July.

 

The London Czech Trio recorded the piece. Miriam Gideon, another American composer whose music appeared on the same LP, supplied the notes for the jacket. Gideon gets down to keys, tempos, and what the cello does, on the reasonable assumption that somebody who has paid for the record might like to know. Elsewhere Newlin translated Schoenberg and wrote about his predecessors. Her first book, Bruckner–Mahler–Schoenberg, came out in 1947, when she was still in her twenties. Given three famous men on a cover and one young woman’s name beneath them, it is easy enough to predict whose work she would be invited to explain for the rest of her life. Gideon’s liner notes reverse the arrangement. For the length of one side of a record, Dika Newlin is the composer who requires explaining. The copy I would wish to own would have both their handwritten signatures on the sleeve.

 

The dust jacket of Dika Newlin’s Bruckner–Mahler–Schoenberg (1947). Of the three men on the cover, only Schoenberg was in a position to complain.

 

One of Newlin’s own students eventually returned the favor. Donna Arnold studied with her in Denton, Texas, where Newlin taught musicology and composition at North Texas State University and presented computer music she had worked on at Bell Labs. Arnold participated in performances, stayed in touch with her teacher after Newlin left for Virginia, and later worked as a librarian in the university’s music collection. She remembered the difficulty of making small talk with a woman capable of causing a commotion in public. She remembered, too, the students and local people who crowded into the hall for a faculty recital. Years later it was possible to read about the punk band in Richmond, Apocowlypso, and suppose that Newlin had become rather a different person in old age. From a seat in Denton, the intervening steps were evidently easier to follow.

 

Dika Newlin, who eventually had students of her own. They, too, remembered a good deal.

 

The university has kept a recording of her recital of March 22, 1972. Scott Joplin opens the proceedings with “Fig Leaf Rag.” There is Morton Feldman, there is Charles Ives, and toward the end there is a piece by Newlin called “Serial Music,” immediately followed by John Cage’s “4′33″.” Anyone who knew of her connection to Schoenberg could have anticipated an exacting five minutes. Arnold remembered the means of production in some detail. Newlin brought out a box of Rice Krispies, poured herself a bowl, added milk, and ate it in front of a microphone. The recording preserves just under five minutes of “Serial Music.” The title works better in the language her teacher had to learn after he left Germany. It also works better if one has written a twelve-tone piano trio, played it in Salzburg, and given an appreciable portion of one’s life to the consideration of what happens when twelve notes are placed in a particular order. Then one is entitled to a little breakfast. I like the billing that evening. Arnold Schoenberg had also given composition lessons to John Cage. Of the two pupils represented at the end of the program, Dika Newlin was the one making all the noise.

 

 

Elise Maret was born in Lausanne in 1972 and studied musicology at the University of Strasbourg. She writes about music and occasionally turns pages for pianists. A disagreement over a repeat in Schubert has made the second occupation less frequent. She remains on good terms with the cellist.

 

 

Listening to Newlin and Schoenberg

 

These ten works are a listening companion to the essay. The first five follow Dika Newlin from the concert hall to a Richmond punk band and a science-fiction film. The next five trace Arnold Schoenberg’s music from the Vienna of Verklärte Nacht to the piano concerto he wrote in Los Angeles. The two halves meet in an unlikely place. A line of poetry that Schoenberg gave to a soprano in his Second String Quartet turns up decades later in a song Newlin sings as a medium in Afterbirth.

 

DIKA NEWLIN

 

  1. Piano Trio, Op. 2 (1948). In the London Czech Trio’s recording, listen for the scherzo. It sounds like the beginning of a new movement, although the opening movement is still unfolding. Newlin fits an entire four-movement trio inside a single sonata form.

 

  1. Meditation on the Passiontide. At her 1972 recital in Denton, Texas, Newlin placed this three-minute meditation immediately before Serial Music. The two pieces are worth hearing in the order she chose.

 

  1. Serial Music. Newlin sat down at a table, poured milk over a bowl of Rice Krispies, and ate it in front of a microphone. For an audience familiar with her training, the title sounded perfectly plausible right up to the moment she produced the cereal.

 

  1. Murder City. A number from Newlin’s solo cabaret act found a second life with her Richmond band, Apocowlypso. Their seven-and-a-half-minute version appears on the 1987 EP Meat the Apocowlypso.

 

  1. Alien Baby. In the film Afterbirth, Newlin opens her song with Stefan George’s image of breathing the air of other planets. By the time she reaches the chorus, the phrase has acquired a rather more literal meaning.

 

ARNOLD SCHOENBERG

 

  1. Verklärte Nacht, Op. 4 (1899). Begin with the original version for string sextet. Much of the drama passes through the violas and cellos as the music moves from anxiety toward tenderness.

 

  1. String Quartet No. 2, Op. 10 (1907–8). A soprano joins the quartet in the third movement. Stay for the opening of the fourth, Entrückung (Rapture), to hear the line Newlin borrowed for Alien Baby.

 

  1. Pierrot lunaire, Op. 21 (1912). Try Schoenberg’s own recording as conductor. In Der Mondfleck, Pierrot tries to brush a patch of moonlight off his coat. The more he fusses, the more intricate the music becomes.

 

  1. Suite for Piano, Op. 25 (1921–23). Charles Rosen’s recording brings out the dance rhythms of the gavotte, musette, and minuet. They give the ear something familiar to follow through Schoenberg’s twelve-tone writing.

 

  1. Piano Concerto, Op. 42 (1942). Newlin later wrote an analysis of this work. In the recording by Mitsuko Uchida and the Cleveland Orchestra under Pierre Boulez, the piano opens with the lilt of a waltz. That opening is worth remembering as the orchestra begins to pull it apart.



Cover image: Arnold Schoenberg teaching composition. On the question of Verdi, at least, one pupil would be filing a minority report.

 
 
 

Comments


selavy-logo.png

A CABINET OF CURIOSITIES ASSEMBLED IN PROSE

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE UPDATES ON NEW POSTINGS FROM SÉLAVY

EMAIL ADDRESS:

THANKS FOR SIGNING UP!

bottom of page